In the aftermath of the Manchester bomb atrocity there were so many stories of the kindness offered by strangers to those who were victims, or were caught up in, the attack – the guy who drove through the night, giving lifts home to those stranded; the woman who guided children to the safety of a local hotel; and all those who offered food and shelter for the night. Then there were the gatherings – in Manchester and Liverpool – which were, as one young woman expressed it on Channel 4 News, ‘more about love and not hatred.’
In this respect there was nothing unusual about Manchester. The kindness of strangers, in Tennessee Williams’ memorable phrase, is a quality we see repeatedly after such terrible events. And though the gatherings and vigils that follow might seem, especially for those with a sceptical or cynical turn of mind, predictable, they do perform a valuable service. Not only do they bring us together when we feel at our most frightened and vulnerable, they also remind us, as George Monbiot insists in his column today, that ‘human cooperation and reciprocity are so normal we scarcely seem to notice them.’ It can be easy after this kind of atrocity – one in which children and young people enjoying their first taste of freedom and independence were sought out to be deliberately blown apart – to conclude that there is no humanity, that we are an intrinsically fallen species.
But, as George Monbiot insists, we should not forget ‘the daily acts of kindness that mark our species: people helping strangers to lift their suitcases on to a train, carrying pushchairs up flights of stairs, giving way to each other in traffic and on the pavement, listening to friends, volunteering for charities, giving their money to causes from which they cannot possibly benefit.’
We might stop to notice the remarkable people who foster children or who take refugees from halfway round the world into their homes, and treat them as members of their families. But we see their tendencies as exceptional, rather than as unalloyed examples of the way that humans are naturally inclined to behave.
Because our minds are attuned to danger and difference, events like the attack on a concert in Manchester dominate perceptions of our species. We look back on the Charlie Hebdo killings in Paris in January 2015 and, remembering the perpetrators, tell ourselves that there is something evil lodged in the human mind. Less salient in our memories are the 3.7 million people in France who took to the streets to march in solidarity with the victims, and the millions who did the same elsewhere in the world. These people, not the few terrorists, represent the human norm.
It would be easy to be cynical about the words of the Mancunian taxi driver who was quoted as saying: ‘We will show whoever’s done this that it doesn’t matter because Manchester – we’re glue, and we stick together when it counts.’ Or to pass off the sentiments expressed from the platform at the Albert Square vigil in Manchester, summed up by local poet Tony Walsh in his not particularly good, but brilliantly performed poem, ‘This is the Place’ with its refrain: ‘Some are born here, some drawn here, but they all call it home.’ But how else are we live together in our gloriously mixed-up cities other than by living by such values?
For the plain fact is that those who perpetrated the Manchester atrocity knew that the murder of two dozen innocents would be seen as an attack on us all, inducing us, ‘blinded by outrage, to forget our humanity and to lash out.’ This, argues George Monbiot, then cultivates a political environment in which terrorists prosper: a nation dominated by fear, a cycle of revenge, and the escalation of conflict.’
Altruism and empathy are what binds us together, and what defines us. We should let no one distract us from this central fact of our nature: neither terrorists nor those who, in response to them, demand that we slam our doors in the faces of an entire community or an entire religion.
Our humanity, in both senses of the word, is on display all over Manchester. You can see it in the queues at the blood donor centres, in the hotels and the private houses that have been thrown open to people stuck in the city after the concert, in the messages posted on social media to help people find missing members of their families, in the donations that thousands of people have made to support victims of the attack, in the taxis giving free rides to hospitals and homes.
Tennessee Williams spoke of the kindness of strangers. But it is a reciprocal thing: not just the kindness shown to us by someone who is a complete stranger, but also the kindness we show to others, perhaps especially to those who have accomplished epic journeys before settling in our home town, people who find themselves in a different land with different customs. We need to feel more often like strangers do, and offer some simple human kindness.
Naomi Shihab Nye is a Palestinian-American whose poems are filled with a humanitarian spirit. In her first collection, Different Ways to Pray (1980), she explored the differences between, and shared experiences of, cultures from California to Texas, from South America to Mexico. In one poem a child declares: ‘Grandma liked me even though my daddy was a Moslem.’ One critic observed that Nye combined an acceptance of different ‘ways to pray’ with an awareness that ‘living in the world can sometimes be difficult.’ Her poems focus on the ordinary, on connections between diverse peoples, and on the perspectives of those in other lands. In one she writes: ‘We move forward, / confident we were born into a large family, / our brothers cover the earth.’
After the World Trade Centre attacks in 2001, the lack of understanding between Americans and Arabs led her to collect poems she had written which dealt with the Middle East and her experiences as an Arab-American into one volume, Nineteen Varieties of Gazelle: Poems of the Middle East. One of her most celebrated poems is ‘Kindness’ which contains these lines:
Before you know what kindness really is
you must lose things,
feel the future dissolve in a moment
like salt in a weakened broth.
What you held in your hand,
what you counted and carefully saved,
all this must go so you know
how desolate the landscape can be
between the regions of kindness.
The complete poem can be read here. But, even better, watch this clip in which Nye reads the poem, prefacing it with an introduction describing how she came to write it. It’s a YouTube gem.
Long ago, another American poet, Ella Wheeler Wilcox (1850 – 1919) wrote this brief untitled verse on the same theme:
So many gods, so many creeds
So many paths that wind and wind,
While just the art of being kind
Is all the sad world needs.
(Thanks, Graeme, for your kind enquiry, and for rousing me from a self-induced torpor. Everything is fine here: the six-week silence has been the result only of lost sleep, early mornings, and constant distraction from being able to think in consecutive sentences. The happy result of having acquired a new puppy, but a circumstance quite challenging when you’re edging close to your seventh decade.)
12 thoughts on “Manchester: the reciprocity of kindness”
Thank you for this. And glad to see you posting – I realised the other day that I hadn’t seen anything from you in a while, not that you aren’t entirely entitled to have a break from blogging!
Gerry I too was begining to worry about you…The bombing is not a thing to wake up to ..but I’m glad your are OK and the words…moving as ever….Thanks….Richard
I first became aware of your blog after the Charlie Hebdo killings because you liked my little “je suis Charlie” image, so I feel introduced to you by tragedy. I wish you didn’t have to write about these things, because they weren’t happening, but appreciate that you do when they do. Thank you, and congratulations on the new family member!
Welcome back…and thankyou!
Reblogged this on World4Justice : NOW! Lobby Forum..
I didn’t wish to disturb you and after my query I realised you have been on twitter (not something I’ve signed up to). However it is always good to find a voice of calm and reason amid turmoil and uncertainty. As for your new companion, he’s a fine looking fellow and assuming he too is a spaniel, great to see he is not docked?
No, I’m grateful for the poke, Graeme. The new companion is indeed a Cocker Spaniel, and as you observe he is not docked. I don’t know if it’s true of all breeds, but here in the UK you don’t see docked dogs any more. Our first was an Old English sheepdog, docked as they all were in the 1980s. You see them now and they are almost unrecognisable, waving their great bushy tails joyfully.
Thanks for your kind thoughts, everyone. I agree, Cath, that we bloggers should be entitled to a break every now and then instead of being hectored by WordPress that we need to raise our production rate to attract more readers! In the post I meant to add the point that there are those for whom kindness is built into their job description: just read this account by a nurse who treated some of the wounded at Stockport’s Stepping Hill hospital – http://bit.ly/2qZtJOy
Yes, thank you for a great blog. Violence and pain get the headlines , but if we slow down long enough to look and to listen there is kindness happening everwhere. Perhaps kindness isnt good enough news for the “meeja” but if itwas, maybe it would be the kind of good news that helps lift peoples spirits and encourage everyone. There is love and kindness in abundance, we just need to encourage more.
On that dreadful day, Manchester city became Manchester united.
Thank you, Gerry, I was not able to read these words before today, as an older ex-pat now in Australia and having some younger family members in Manchester who are keen on up to date concerts I was so concerned that I was not able to settle down at all until I had managed to contact them after that awful scary news on the box. Your blog reminded me of wartime experiences when people were generally much kinder to each other than at any time before or since. Kindness is the most valuable quality, in times of trouble it is only kindness that can really help. P.S. My school friend lived in Dickens Lane, Poynton…a few years before your time, I believe
Small world, Nellie. I lived just round the corner from Dickens Lane – in Clumber Road.