In the UK, with UKIP in the ascendant stoking up its anti-immigration message, we hear both Labour and Conservative politicians, running scared of a section of the electorate, tacking daily towards UKIP’s positions. But what if our politicians were brave enough to take on the racists and the narrow-minded?  That’s what the German Chancellor Angela Merkel has done in her new year address to the nation.

Migrants after disembarking from the Ezadeen
Syrian migrants from the ‘ghost ship’ Ezadeen in Corigliano Calabro harbour on Saturday

Context first: in Germany as in the UK, mainstream parties are being challenged by a populist ant-immigrant movement, the right-wing, racist Pegida, or Patriotische Europäer gegen die Islamisierung des Abendlandes (Patriotic Europeans against the Islamisation of the West).  It has been gaining support in Germany generally for several months, but especially in Dresden, where rallies have taken place every Monday for the last two months.  Tomorrow the eleventh demonstration is due to take place, with another rally planned for Cologne, where the lights of the cathedral will be turned off in a mark of the church’s disapproval of Pegida. (You can read about Pegida in today’s Observer).

As with UKIP here, the growth of Pegida has led to calls for the government to tighten asylum rules and speed up the deportation process to appease voters. But in her new year speech, Merkel’s responded boldly, saying that when Pegida demonstrators chant ‘we are the people’ (co-opting a slogan from the rallies that led up to the fall of the Berlin Wall 25 years ago), ‘What they really mean is: you are not one of us, because of your skin colour or your religion’. She continued:

I say to all those who go to such demonstrations: do not follow those who have called the rallies, because all too often they have prejudice, a chilliness, even hatred in their hearts. It goes without saying that we help them and take in people who seek refuge with us.

Merkel making her new year address

Angela Merkel making her televised new year address

Merkel pointed out that Germany has received more than 200,000 applications from asylum seekers this year, making it the country accepting the largest number of refugees in the world. The reason for this, she added, is that the number of refugees in the world this year hasn’t been so high since World War II. Merkel insisted that children of persecuted parents should be able to grow up in Germany under peaceful circumstances – this was something the country could be proud of.

Merkel’s words come on the same weekend when we have seen the two crew-less ‘ghost’ ships arrive in Italy, carrying hundreds of refugees fleeing the Syrian civil war and the advance of Isis. As the Guardian reports, they are just part of the largest wave of mass-migration the world has seen since the end of the second world war:

Wars in Syria, Libya and Iraq, severe repression in Eritrea, and spiralling instability across much of the Arab world have all contributed to the displacement of around 16.7 million refugees worldwide. A further 33.3 million people are “internally displaced” within their own war-torn countries, forcing many of those originally from the Middle East to cross the lesser evil of the Mediterranean in increasingly dangerous ways, all in the distant hope of a better life in Europe.

“These numbers are unprecedented,” said Leonard Doyle, spokesman for the International Organisation for Migration. “In terms of refugees and migrants, nothing has been seen like this since world war two, and even then [the flow of migration] was in the opposite direction.”

Angela Merkel addressed this in her speech:

One consequence of these wars and crises is that worldwide there are more refugees than we have seen since the second world war. Many literally escaped death. It goes without saying that we help them and take in people who seek refuge with us.

Pointing out that the German population is ageing rapidly, she called immigration ‘a gain for all of us’.  Speaking about the case of a Kurdish refugee who had settled in Germany, she said that it is ‘perhaps the biggest compliment’ for Germany to call itself a place ‘where the children of the persecuted can grow up without fear’.

I would be mightily impressed if Cameron, Miliband, or another British politician expressed such views so clearly.

Inside the Ezadeen

Inside the  ‘ghost ship’ Ezadeen – formerly used for transporting cattle.

Update 6 January: In a three-page special in Bild, 80 prominent Germans – politicians of all stripes, faith leaders, business managers and trade union leaders, entertainers, football managers and top athletes say NO to Pegida and state the case for a cosmopolitan and tolerant Germany. Gurdian report here.  See also: How Germans documented Pegida’s far-right protests on social media.

Footnote: for an example of a brilliantly imaginative protest by German villagers against neo-Nazis, see this: German town tricks neo-Nazis into raising thousands of euros for anti-extremist charity (Guardian, November 2014)

See also


6 thoughts on “Angela Merkel denounces those who ‘have prejudice, a chilliness, even hatred in their hearts’

  1. Great focus; the broadest lesson from WWII I have always thought is that, “Zusammen, es ist immer besser”: Go our Angela!

  2. Well said indeed. I fear that not much will change whilst we still have nation states. Seems incredible that on the eve of WW1 there were still no passports nor border controls in this Country. I’m reminded of a comment from a F.E. college lecturer of mine, he suggested that if only Germany had been allowed to expand slightly to the East there would have been no need for WW2. He was German and lectured at Childwall Hall, Liverpool, in 1973. Perhaps you can remember him Gerry? Can’t recall his name. He used to drive an Orange coloured VW Beetle and would stay up on parliamentary election nights until every result was in. I’ve now just remembered the content of the sandwiches he would make to see him through. This blog is a Proustian Madeline cake. I now feel the need to return to the Childwall Abbey, drink a pint of Guinness and see what that rakes up. Or has Lime Pictures taken that over too?

    1. I do remember him, David, since I taught at Childwall as well. His name was Peter Edgington, a fine man. He died in the late 80s, of a heart-attack I think. Glad you’re enjoying the Madeline experience!

      1. Apologies Gerry. Please allow me a further indulgence. Edgington! A man ready to share his cigarettes with students down on their luck. Towards the end of my time at Childwall, some of us, probably unconsciously, finding the separation difficult, cajoled him into driving us to the Yung Wah restaurant in Nelson Street. We treated him. Now this was a man who was fond of his tucker but he treated the occasion like he was eating the best Cantonese he had ever eaten. Afterwards he directed us into the pub (name escapes) across the road. There, he introduced us to friendly night workers, a statue of the Virgin Mary and the identical twin brothers who ran the pub. It was like he was family. By the end of the night, we were family too.

        Thank you.

  3. Well, written, Gerry! I´m following here in Germany how this is going. I´m pleased with her stance on this – it´s very important. But unfortunately her fellow conservative member of the government – the Bavarian CSU, my “local” party” ,are uttering the usual comments – Merkel has moved too far to the right amongst other idiot comments. The chairman of the German craftsman guild has urged that young refugees should be encouraged to take up apprenticeships here to fill the shortfall in Germans! A sensible attitude to resolving more than one problem!
    Thanks for posting this, it shows up the Brit. politicos for what they are – and oddly enough how even German conservatives have a more social stance than Cameron et al!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.